Storytelling That Sells: Why Facts Aren’t Enough

August 28, 2025

If you’ve ever sat through a sales pitch, you know the difference.


One person rattles off features, warranties, timelines. Another tells a story — about a real customer, a struggle, and a solution.


Guess which one sticks with you?


That’s the power of story. And it’s older than business itself.


Before there were logos or websites, people gathered around fires to make sense of chaos, to connect, to trust.

Facts Tell. Stories Sell.


Most of us default to facts. It feels safe to talk about numbers, processes, or credentials.


But nobody buys because of facts alone.


Here’s the truth: people make decisions emotionally first, and justify them logically later. A story lowers resistance, creates connection, and transfers trust.


That’s why facts tell. But stories? Stories sell.

The 3 Stories You Need in Business


You don’t need a polished speech. You need three stories in your back pocket:


  1. Your Personal Story – Why do you care? What shaped you?
  2. Your Company Story – Why do you exist beyond making money?
  3. Your Customer Story – What proof do you have that your work changes lives?


These don’t need to be long. Just real. Just true.



And every great story has the same structure: a problem, a struggle, a solution, and an outcome.

A Quick Example


You could say:


“We started this company in 2016 and we’ve done over 2,000 installs.”


Or you could say:


“In 2016, our founder’s dad got ripped off by a roofing company after a storm. $18,000 in damage. No accountability. That moment changed everything. He didn’t just want to fix roofs — he wanted to fix the way people were treated. That’s why we do it differently.”


Which one do you remember?


That’s the power of story.

Sharpen Your Story


Whether you’re pitching an investor, meeting a homeowner, or leading your team — your story is what makes you unforgettable.


It’s not about being perfect. It’s about being human.


At The Sales Pond, we don’t train scripts. We sharpen stories. We practice telling the truth with clarity and emotion — so people lean in.


Because the sale isn’t in your script.


The sale is in your story.


👉 Want to sharpen your storytelling and grow alongside other entrepreneurs and sales leaders?


The Sales Pond is part of The Pond, our community designed for visionaries who want clarity, freedom, and impact.

Whether you're driving, building, or reflecting — catch every episode of The Big Fish Cares Podcast on your favorite platform.

Where Real Conversations Live

A button that says listen on apple podcasts on a white background.
A youtube logo that says watch and listen on youtube
A button that says listen on spotify on it

Looking for more? Start here.

Podcast guest Matt Brasic shares his journey of divorce, faith, and rediscovering purpose on the Big
September 4, 2025
Matt Brasic opens up about divorce, faith, and finding purpose after misalignment. A raw story of letting go, clarity, and personal awakening.
August 25, 2025
I used to think winning was about stacking more wins. Build it. Grow it. Repeat. Lately, I’m a lot more interested in how we build without breaking the people we love — including ourselves. This week on Big Fish Cares , I sat down with Jonathan D. Reynolds (CEO, Titus Talent Strategies ) to talk about purpose, fatherhood, faith, and the simple truth he keeps coming back to:“Most company problems are people problems.” The 15-year-old question At 15, Jonathan asked his parents what he was “created to do.” Their answer: live in the service of others . He didn’t love that answer then. He lives it now — helping leaders find the right people, and helping people find the work they’re built for. That turned into a business and a calling. My advice would be: if you’re still waiting for a lightning-bolt purpose, serve where you stand. Purpose shows up when your service gets specific. For-profit, for good Titus calls itself for-profit for good: build a healthy company and use the profits to help those who need it most. They set a goal to give $30M by 2030 and are already about 70% of the way there . That’s not performative — that’s operationalized generosity. What I would recommend: design comp plans and culture like a family you’d be proud of. Jonathan’s team incentive started as his kids’ allowance…and it works. Leading at work vs. leading at home We talked about the gap a lot of us feel: Compassionate at work, impatient at home. Driver in the office, bulldozer in the living room. Jonathan built a transition ritual before walking through the door — slow down, ask better questions at dinner (“What was the hardest part of your day?” “What brought you joy?”), and be there. That’s leadership too. When you can’t fix it Jonathan’s parents have been detained by the Taliban in Afghanistan . No charges. No clear path. He stood outside the White House with his daughter asking for help. Impossible to carry — and yet this line anchored him: “I can’t control that. I can control my trust. I can control my love. I can control whether I get bitter.” Stay low. Stay humble. Control what you can control. That isn’t a slogan. It’s survival for leaders getting hit by real life. Try this week One conversation: name a “people problem” you’re avoiding and address it directly. One boundary: pick a start/stop for work and keep it. One practice: give something away (time, cash, credit). Open hands move resources faster. If you’re carrying a lot right now, you’re not alone. The goal isn’t a perfect life. The goal is a grounded one. Listen to the episode: Apple Podcasts → [link] · All apps → [link] If this resonated, come do the work with us inside The Pond — founders who want growth and peace in the same breath. [Join the waitlist]
Jonathan Reynolds on  Purpose and People | The Big Fish Cares Podcast
August 21, 2025
Benny Fisher talks with Jonathan D. Reynolds about purpose, fatherhood, faith, and why most company problems are people problems. Listen on Apple or any podcast app.
Show More
Podcast guest Matt Brasic shares his journey of divorce, faith, and rediscovering purpose on the Big
September 4, 2025
Matt Brasic opens up about divorce, faith, and finding purpose after misalignment. A raw story of letting go, clarity, and personal awakening.
August 25, 2025
I used to think winning was about stacking more wins. Build it. Grow it. Repeat. Lately, I’m a lot more interested in how we build without breaking the people we love — including ourselves. This week on Big Fish Cares , I sat down with Jonathan D. Reynolds (CEO, Titus Talent Strategies ) to talk about purpose, fatherhood, faith, and the simple truth he keeps coming back to:“Most company problems are people problems.” The 15-year-old question At 15, Jonathan asked his parents what he was “created to do.” Their answer: live in the service of others . He didn’t love that answer then. He lives it now — helping leaders find the right people, and helping people find the work they’re built for. That turned into a business and a calling. My advice would be: if you’re still waiting for a lightning-bolt purpose, serve where you stand. Purpose shows up when your service gets specific. For-profit, for good Titus calls itself for-profit for good: build a healthy company and use the profits to help those who need it most. They set a goal to give $30M by 2030 and are already about 70% of the way there . That’s not performative — that’s operationalized generosity. What I would recommend: design comp plans and culture like a family you’d be proud of. Jonathan’s team incentive started as his kids’ allowance…and it works. Leading at work vs. leading at home We talked about the gap a lot of us feel: Compassionate at work, impatient at home. Driver in the office, bulldozer in the living room. Jonathan built a transition ritual before walking through the door — slow down, ask better questions at dinner (“What was the hardest part of your day?” “What brought you joy?”), and be there. That’s leadership too. When you can’t fix it Jonathan’s parents have been detained by the Taliban in Afghanistan . No charges. No clear path. He stood outside the White House with his daughter asking for help. Impossible to carry — and yet this line anchored him: “I can’t control that. I can control my trust. I can control my love. I can control whether I get bitter.” Stay low. Stay humble. Control what you can control. That isn’t a slogan. It’s survival for leaders getting hit by real life. Try this week One conversation: name a “people problem” you’re avoiding and address it directly. One boundary: pick a start/stop for work and keep it. One practice: give something away (time, cash, credit). Open hands move resources faster. If you’re carrying a lot right now, you’re not alone. The goal isn’t a perfect life. The goal is a grounded one. Listen to the episode: Apple Podcasts → [link] · All apps → [link] If this resonated, come do the work with us inside The Pond — founders who want growth and peace in the same breath. [Join the waitlist]
Jonathan Reynolds on  Purpose and People | The Big Fish Cares Podcast
August 21, 2025
Benny Fisher talks with Jonathan D. Reynolds about purpose, fatherhood, faith, and why most company problems are people problems. Listen on Apple or any podcast app.
Help Rewrite Claire’s Story With Hope
August 7, 2025
Claire is still in the hospital—but you can help. Donate, share, or pray. Every action brings healing and hope to her family.
The Art of Clay & Spirit: Brad Dalton’s Mission to Inspire Through Gifts BRAD DALTON
August 7, 2025
In this heartfelt episode of The Big Fish Cares Podcast, host Benny Fisher sits down with Brad Dalton, the artist and founder behind Clay and Spirit and New Creation Pottery. Brad’s mission? To handcraft deeply personal, faith-filled gifts that speak to the soul using clay as his canvas and spirit as his guide. Inspired by a calling from God and the enduring encouragement of his late friend John Ruhlin, Brad creates “living artifacts” pottery pieces that celebrate love, legacy, and personal affirmation. Each creation begins with a story, shaped by heartfelt words from the giver, and ends as a one-of-a-kind piece that becomes a treasured reminder of connection. Brad opens up about his artistic journey, how he rediscovered clay in college, and how he turned a creative spark into a ministry of healing, encouragement, and faith. From his workshop to homes across the country, Brad’s gifts are transforming hearts one vessel at a time. Key Moments: 00:00 The Big Fish Cares Intro 03:03 Brad's Early Creative Memories 06:06 The Role of Faith in Life & Art 13:40 Meeting John Ruhlin & The Artifact Mug 21:32 John Ruhlin's Legacy and Spirit 27:33 The Creative Process of the Artifact Mug 31:46 Meaningful Gifting and Emotional Impact 37:35 Clay and Spirit: Integrating Faith & Art 41:41 Being a Pure Vessel & Recovering Wonder 45:44 The Spiritual Foundations 51:00 Advice for Artists & Meaningful Giving 56:06 Leaving a Legacy of Love 01:00:06 Dreams, Loss, and RC Street Racing 01:04:11 Reflections, Gratitude, and Final Thoughts 01:11:11 Closing Remarks & Podcast Wrap Up Want to order an artifact mug for you or a love one? Get in contact with Brad Dalton: https://artifactmug.com/ 🌐 Instagram: / clay_and_spirit 👉 Facebook: / brad.dalton.56 🌐 LinkedIn: / brad-dalton-421886197 🎙️ Connect with Host Benny Fisher: 🌐 Official Website: https://www.bennyfisher.com 📸 Instagram: / bigfish.benny 👉 Facebook: / fisherbenny 🌐 LinkedIn: / fisherbenny Watch the full episode now and subscribe to The Big Fish Cares Podcast for more conversations that matter!
Benny Fisher on Visionary Leadership, the Future of Work, and Building Big Fish Contracting
July 29, 2025
Benny Fisher on Visionary Leadership, the Future of Work, and Building Big Fish Contracting Benny Fisher, entrepreneur and Visionary Navigator, joins Eric McKenna on The Eric McKenna Project Podcast #386 for an in-depth conversation about the future of business, technology, and personal growth. In this episode, Benny shares his journey from building and exiting Big Fish Contracting , one of Pittsburgh’s Top 50 Fastest-Growing Companies, to guiding entrepreneurs toward alignment, creativity, and sustainable success. He and Eric dive into the big questions every business leader should be thinking about: What You’ll Learn in This Episode How AI and automation will reshape the future of work and entrepreneurship Why real human connection is becoming the most valuable currency in a digital world The role of curiosity, creativity, and free will in unlocking your potential Lessons from scaling and successfully exiting Big Fish Contracting Why transparency, emotional intelligence, and innovation are the keys to future-ready businesses Why This Episode Matters As a founder or visionary leader, navigating the future means more than just keeping up with technology—it’s about creating space to think differently, lead with purpose, and grow without losing yourself . Whether you’re an entrepreneur, business owner, or someone curious about where the world is heading, this episode will inspire you to slow down, think bigger, and embrace the changes coming your way.  📺 Watch the full conversation now and explore Benny’s insights on leadership, innovation, and the future of work.
Not a coach but  visionary navigator
July 24, 2025
Discover why Benny Fisher calls himself a Visionary Navigator—and how his journey with Gino Wickman helped him redefine leadership, alignment, and freedom.
Redefining Wealth: Joel Miller on Real Estate, Relationships & Faith
July 2, 2025
Redefining Wealth: Joel Miller on Real Estate, Relationships & Faith
Firm Feedback in a Fragile World-Jeff Hancher
June 17, 2025
In this powerful episode of The Big Fish Cares Podcast, host Benny Fisher sits down with Jeff Hancher: Army veteran, Fortune 500 leader, leadership coach, and author of the new book Firm Feedback in a Fragile World.
A group of people are standing in front of a large screen in a room.
June 17, 2025
I’m Nes, Benny’s Marketing Director, and usually the person behind the scenes helping bring all the brand content to life. But this week, I stepped out from behind the laptop and into the room. I flew into Pittsburgh to work with Benny in person for the first time since August. We had content to plan, creative to shape, and new ideas to bring to life. But what I didn’t expect was to walk into a moment that would stay with me long after the cameras stopped rolling. That afternoon, Jeff Hancher walked onto set to record an episode of The Big Fish Cares Podcast. I knew Jeff’s background. His leadership coaching, his military service, his Fortune 500 success. But I didn’t know the story behind all that. Not the way he told it. From the moment he sat down, something shifted in the room. He spoke with a depth and clarity that made everything else fade into the background. He talked about growing up in poverty. About watching his mom cut her medication in half just to make it last. About holding her during seizures. About wondering if he’d ever escape the weight of where he came from. And he didn’t just say it. He felt it. So did we. I’ve worked on podcasts before, but this was my first time in the room as one was being recorded. I thought I’d be focused on angles, lighting, social content. But instead, I found myself locked into every word. There were moments when I had actual goosebumps. You could hear it in the silence, in the weight of the pauses. It was real. And it was rare. But Jeff didn’t just speak about struggle. He spoke about leadership with a kind of intentionality that stuck with me. He talked about the power of culture. How the environment we create can either crush people or call them into something greater. He talked about feedback, mentorship, and what it means to show up for others with strength and softness. He told stories of mentors who taught him how to lead. Not just in theory, but in practice. Who helped him find his voice, carry himself with confidence, and rise without forgetting where he came from. And when he talked about losing his mother — the heartbreak, the timing, the unraveling that almost followed — it didn’t feel like a story. It felt like grief in real time. And then came the turning point. One leader stepped in and refused to let him quit. That moment hit me. Hard. It reminded me why I do this work. Why stories matter. Why leadership, when done right, isn’t just about strategy. It’s about people. Jeff’s new book, Firm Feedback in a Fragile World, goes even deeper into these lessons. It’s a book about leadership, yes. But also about healing, purpose, and what it means to lead from experience, not ego. If you’ve ever felt unseen, unsure, or like your story disqualifies you, listen to this episode. Then read Jeff’s book. Let it remind you that some of the most powerful leaders are the ones who had to fight their way forward and chose to bring others with them. �55356;�57241; Watch the full episode with Jeff Hancher on The Big Fish Cares Podcast Now available on YouTube, Spotify, and Apple Podcasts. �55357;�56536; Grab Jeff’s book, Firm Feedback in a Fragile World, here → https://www.firmfeedbackbook.com/ And if you ever get the chance to be in the room—take it. Some stories deserve to be felt up close.
Show More