Emotional Intelligence starts after the test
You can't see the back of your own head. That's why a roofing owner needs more than a test result.
The short version: An emotional intelligence, DISC or Predictive Index assessment doesn't make you a better leader of your roofing company. It gives you a mirror. The change happens after: one behavior, noticed in the moment, practiced differently, with someone you trust telling you what they see. The assessment names the work. Deliberate practice changes the leader.
In September I walked a leadership team through their DISC results.
You know the moment. Everybody gets their report. Everybody reads their own page first. There's a little laughing, a little "that's so me," somebody reads a line out loud about the guy across the table. And then the energy in the room says the same thing it always says.
We did it. We're done.
That's the moment I worry about. Because nothing has changed yet. Nobody in that room is more emotionally intelligent than they were an hour ago. They just got a mirror.
A mirror is not a transformation
Taking one does not make you emotionally intelligent. It gives you a mirror. The growth happens after you see what's there.
I believe an assessment is one of the most useful tools an owner can buy. I use them with almost every team I work with. DISC, Predictive Index, Kolbe, the EQ assessment that comes in the back of a book. I love them.
But most owners treat the report like a diploma. They frame it, they quote it, they use it to explain themselves. "I'm a high D, that's just how I am." That's not self-awareness. That's a permission slip.
The assessment names the work. Deliberate practice changes the leader.
The gap between who you are and who you've been pretending to be
The part of that DISC session that hit hardest wasn't anybody's main style. It was the gap. The difference between how someone is naturally wired and how they've adapted to survive their role.
Every leader adjusts. The direct guy learns patience. The quiet processor learns to speak up sooner. The relationship-first leader learns to hold a harder line. That's growth, and it's good.
But when someone has to wear a completely different costume every single day just to make it through the job, adaptation turns into a tax. In a roofing company you see it all the time, like the owner who came up selling and now spends his whole week running production. The work still gets done. The stress just goes invisible.
What I want every team to hear is this: don't use the gap as a verdict. Use it as a conversation. What part of this role drains you most? Where are you overcompensating? What should be developed, and what should be redesigned?
Five percent, not a new personality
You don't need to rebuild your whole personality this month. Nobody does. You need to become five percent more aware in the moments that matter most.
Here's what you need to do. It's four steps and it's boring on purpose:
- Choose one behavior. One.
- Notice the moment it shows up. The production meeting, the homeowner at the kitchen table, the text from your spouse.
- Practice a different response, even a clumsy one.
- Ask someone you trust for feedback. Then repeat until the new response is more natural than the old reaction.
That's it. That's the whole program. Do that for thirty days and you'll have done more than most owners do with five assessments.
If you want the best starting point, Travis Bradberry and Jean Greaves wrote Emotional Intelligence 2.0. Four skills, a built-in self-assessment and plain words for what you feel and how you handle it. If your team speaks in colors, Thomas Erikson's Surrounded by Idiots is a useful shortcut. Just remember it's a shortcut, not personality science.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. I only link books I've actually handed to someone.
Old Benny would have fired back
I'll tell you where my own mirror shows up.
When somebody comes at me, Old Benny would have started firing back left and right. I've got good wisdom at this point. Most days. The behavior I'm still training is the half second before I answer, and I don't always win it.
Timothy Gallwey's The Inner Game of Tennis is the best book I know on that half second. It's a tennis book that I hand to roofers. Self 1 is the voice yelling "don't screw this up." Self 2 actually knows how to hit the ball. Quiet Self 1 and Self 2 does the work. Best audiobook in the whole Nine Deep program.
Somebody has to see behind you
Here's the problem with a mirror. It only shows you what's in front of you. You can't see the back of your own head.
That's why every roofing owner needs one deep, trusted relationship with someone who has been through it. Someone who can see the things he can't see himself and say them out loud. I started, built and sold my own retail roofing company, so I know how hard it is to see yourself clearly from that chair. You need someone who walks with you and gets real with you.
Dan Millman's Way of the Peaceful Warrior is about exactly this. A college gymnast who has it all meets an old gas station attendant he calls Socrates, and Socrates shows him his own mind is the problem. It reads like a novel, which helps if you don't love reading.
I'll say the unspoken part, because I always do. I can be very influential, and when I believe something it's going to sound like the only way to go. I don't want anybody getting too dependent on Benny. The goal of a navigator is to help you see clearly enough that you trust your own eyes again.
I believe truth is the only thing that ever transformed anybody. An assessment hands you a piece of it. What you do with it is the whole test.
So pull out the last assessment you took. The one sitting in a drawer or a PDF you haven't opened since the workshop.
What's the one behavior on that page you already knew about, and who have you given permission to call you on it?
Questions Roofing Owners Ask Me About Assessments
Does taking a DISC or EQ assessment make you a better leader?
No. An assessment gives you a mirror, not a transformation. The growth happens after, when you pick one behavior, notice it in the moment, practice a different response and ask someone you trust for feedback.
What should a roofing leadership team do after an assessment?
Look at the gap between natural and adapted behavior, and treat it as a conversation, not a verdict. Ask what drains each person, where they're overcompensating, and what should be developed versus redesigned.
How do you improve emotional intelligence at work?
Choose one behavior and train it for thirty days. Notice the moment it shows up, respond differently, and get feedback. Aim for five percent more awareness in the moments that matter, not a new personality.
Why does a roofing owner need an outside advisor?
Because a mirror only shows what's in front of you. An advisor who has built and sold a retail roofing company can see what you can't and say it out loud, so you learn to trust your own eyes again.
If you're a hardworking retail roofing owner and you want someone who can see what's behind you and walk with you while you train the one behavior that matters, let's talk. Book a free 15-minute Clarity Call with me here.
See every book I hand roofing owners on the full reading list.
Benny Fisher
Visionary Navigator
See you in The Pond.
Whether you're driving, building, or reflecting — catch every episode of The Big Fish Cares Podcast on your favorite platform.
Where Real Conversations Live
Looking for more? Start here.



